With the advancement of machine learning and artificial intelligence technologies, the development of intelligent applications is progressing rapidly. This has prompted semiconductor companies to continuously innovate and introduce accelerators and processors, such as TPUs and CPUs, to handle increasingly complex applications. For practitioners in the field of deep learning, NVIDIA GPUs have always been the primary choice. However, the emergence of Google's TPU chip is poised to change this landscape. In this article, we will compare TPUs and GPUs, but before delving into the details, there are several key points to understand.
What is TPU
TPU, short for tensor processing unit, is a specialized integrated circuit (ASIC) designed by Google, distinct from NVIDIA's GPU series. Google designed the TPU from scratch and began internal usage in 2015, opening it to the public in 2018. The TPU can be provided as a standalone chip or a cloud service version. Cloud TPUs can handle complex matrix and vector operations at astonishing speeds, accelerating machine learning tasks that involve training neural networks using TensorFlow software.
The Google Brain team developed an open-source machine learning platform with TensorFlow, allowing researchers, developers, and businesses to utilize cloud TPU hardware to build and operate artificial intelligence models.
TPUs significantly reduce the time required to train complex and robust neural network models to achieve accuracy. While training deep learning models using GPUs may take several weeks, TPUs require only a fraction of that time.
After several years of development, TPU has been released in four versions. The following is its development timeline.
|
TPUv1 |
TPUv2 |
TPUv3 |
TPUv4 |
Edge v1
|
|
|
Data introduced |
2016 |
2017 |
2018 |
2021 |
2018 |
|
Process node |
28nm |
16nm |
16nm |
7nm |
/ |
|
Die size(mm²） |
28 |
32 |
32 |
144 |
/ |
|
On-chip memory（MiB ） |
331 |
＜625 |
＜700 |
＜400 |
/ |
|
Clock speed（MHz） |
700 |
700 |
940 |
1050 |
/ |
|
Memory（GB） |
8GB DDR3 |
16GBHBM |
32GB HBM |
8GB |
/ |
|
TDP（GB） |
75 |
280 |
450 |
175 |
2 |
|
TOPS(Tera operations per second） |
23 |
45 |
90 |
/ |
4 |
The above are typical products of TPU, with TPUv1-3 not available for external sale, only providing corresponding cloud computing services. EdgeTPU is used for edge-side inference and related development kits are available for external sale.
What is GPU
GPU was originally developed as a specialized graphics processor, primarily used for graphics rendering and accelerating graphic processing tasks, often confused with a graphics card (which has more hardware components). The core design concept of GPUs lies in highly parallel architecture, with a large number of computing units (stream processors) capable of processing multiple data simultaneously (making them suitable for data mining). They excel at simultaneously handling multiple tasks, such as converting data in a computer into visually appealing images on a screen. In computational tasks, GPUs leverage their parallel computing advantages to accelerate processing tasks like deep learning training, scientific computing, and other large-scale data-intensive operations.
GPU (Graphics Processing Unit) is a graphics processing unit and is the core component of a graphics card. The term "graphics card" typically refers to a complete hardware device that includes the GPU and other necessary components (such as RAM, cooling system, interfaces, etc.). Therefore, strictly speaking, a GPU is not a graphics card, but it is indeed a crucial part of what makes up a graphics card. In everyday language, people sometimes interchangeably use the terms GPU and graphics card, but accurately speaking, the GPU is the main chip or processor within the graphics card.
The History of GPU Development
|
The 1980s |
- 1983: The American company Silicon Graphics (SGI) introduced the first workstation specifically designed for graphics processing, the IRIS 1000. - 1985: NVIDIA was founded, marking the start of its focus on the research and development of graphics processor technology. |
|
The 1990s
|
1999: NVIDIA released the GeForce 256, the world's first true GPU, which integrated graphics rendering and geometry calculation functions, setting the direction for the future development of GPUs. |
|
The early 21st century |
- 2000: ATI Technologies (now AMD) released the Radeon R100 series graphics cards, incorporating programmable rendering pipelines. - 2006: NVIDIA launched the GeForce 8800 series, introducing unified shader architecture for the first time, further enhancing graphics processing efficiency. |
|
Recent years' development |
- From 2006 to the present: GPUs have emerged as important tools in fields such as deep learning and scientific computing, becoming essential for general-purpose parallel computing. - 2012: NVIDIA released the Kepler architecture, enhancing the GPU's performance in computational tasks. - 2016: NVIDIA introduced the Pascal architecture, incorporating specialized deep learning cores called Tensor Cores, accelerating deep learning tasks. -2020: NVIDIA unveiled the Ampere architecture, further improving the GPU's performance in deep learning and scientific computing.
|
The differences between TPU and GPU
|
TPU |
GPU |
|
|
Design purpose |
Specifically designed to accelerate deep learning tasks, and specifically optimized for deep learning frameworks such as TensorFlow. |
Originally designed for graphics processing, it is widely used in areas such as deep learning and scientific computing due to its highly parallel computing capabilities. |
|
Architectural feature |
Specially optimized for deep learning operations such as matrix multiplication, with efficient matrix multiplication units. |
With a large number of parallel processing units, it is suitable for a variety of computationally intensive tasks, including deep learning training and reasoning. |
|
Power consumption and performance ratio |
Tpus focus on machine learning and optimized hardware design, capable of delivering powerful computing performance and relatively low power consumption. In terms of power consumption and performance ratio, TPU has significant advantages. |
Gpus consume relatively high power due to their highly parallel computing nature, but can significantly accelerate computing tasks under the right circumstances. In terms of power consumption and performance ratio, GPU has good scalability. |
|
adaptability |
Mainly used to accelerate deep learning tasks, such as image recognition, natural language processing, etc., suitable for machine learning workloads on cloud service platforms such as Google ecloud, and play an important role in large-scale machine learning applications such as data centers. |
Widely used in graphics processing and scientific computing, in games, animation, virtual reality, cryptography, weather forecast and other fields have a wide range of applications. |
|
Price |
TPUs are proprietary to Google Cloud and may have a higher cost compared to GPUs. |
GPUs are available from different manufacturers and more widely accessible to researchers, developers and hobbyists at different price points. |
|
calculated performance |
It has outstanding performance advantages in the field of machine learning, and its special hardware design and optimized instruction set enable efficient performance of tensor calculations. Tpus excel at deep learning tasks. |
With the capability of large-scale parallel computing, by having multiple core and scheduling units, can process multiple threads at the same time, providing high parallel computing performance. Gpus excel in areas such as graphics rendering, image processing and scientific computing. |
|
availability |
TPU is unique to Google Cloud Services |
Gpus are available from a variety of manufacturers and can be used by researchers, developers, and hobbyists alike |
TPU and GPU, which one is better?
TPU and GPU each have their own strengths, and the choice of which is better depends on specific application scenarios and requirements. Here are some common situations where TPUs may be more suitable than GPUs:
Deep learning acceleration: TPUs are specifically designed to accelerate deep learning tasks, especially in large-scale machine learning applications and deep neural network training, where TPUs typically outperform GPUs.
Power efficiency: TPUs generally have lower power consumption compared to GPUs, making them more suitable for scenarios requiring high efficiency while controlling power consumption.
Google Cloud platform: TPUs are hardware accelerators exclusive to the Google Cloud platform. If you are using Google Cloud for machine learning tasks, leveraging the advantages of TPUs is recommended.
Large-scale parallel computing: For scenarios requiring large-scale parallel computing, massive data processing, and deep learning tasks, TPUs may be more suitable than GPUs.
However, there are also situations where GPUs may be more suitable:
General computing needs: GPUs are general-purpose parallel computing devices suitable for a wide range of computing fields, including graphics rendering, scientific computing, data analysis, etc. Therefore, GPUs are more suitable for scenarios requiring flexibility across various computing tasks.
Cost considerations: TPUs are typically more expensive. If budget is limited or cost-sensitive, choosing GPUs may be more cost-effective.
Widespread support: GPUs have a broader support and application ecosystem in the market, with more software and tool support, making them suitable for various application scenarios and requirements.
In conclusion, both TPUs and GPUs have their own strengths and suitable application scenarios. The choice between them depends on specific requirements, budget, and application scenarios. TPUs may be more suitable for deep learning tasks, large-scale machine learning applications, and scenarios requiring high efficiency, while GPUs may be more suitable for general computing, cost considerations, and broad support.
TPUs and GPUs in the field of artificial intelligence
TPUs (Tensor Processing Units) and GPUs (Graphics Processing Units) are both important hardware accelerators commonly used in the field of artificial intelligence (AI). They are designed to perform complex mathematical computations efficiently, which are fundamental to AI workloads such as machine learning and deep learning.
GPUs, originally developed for graphics rendering in video games, have gained significant popularity in AI due to their parallel processing capabilities. GPUs excel at performing computations on large matrices, which are inherent to many AI algorithms. They are particularly effective in training deep neural networks, where the computations can be distributed across thousands of cores in parallel. GPUs are widely used for tasks such as image recognition, natural language processing, and reinforcement learning. Popular GPU manufacturers include NVIDIA, AMD, and Intel.
TPUs, on the other hand, are specialized AI accelerators developed by Google specifically for machine learning workloads. TPUs are designed to optimize the performance of TensorFlow, a popular deep learning framework. They are highly efficient at executing matrix multiplications, which are fundamental to neural network computations. TPUs are specifically designed to accelerate the inference and training processes of deep neural networks. Google has integrated TPUs into its cloud infrastructure, allowing developers to leverage their power for AI tasks. TPUs are known for their exceptional performance per watt, which makes them popular for large-scale AI deployments.
While GPUs remain a versatile choice for many AI applications, TPUs offer specific advantages in certain scenarios. TPUs are particularly beneficial in large-scale distributed training, where the ability to process massive datasets quickly is crucial. They also excel in scenarios where power efficiency is a priority, such as edge computing or mobile devices. However, it's worth noting that TPUs are tightly integrated with TensorFlow and might require some adjustments to existing codebases to fully leverage their capabilities.
In summary, both TPUs and GPUs play significant roles in the field of AI. GPUs are widely used for general-purpose AI tasks and have a broader range of applications, while TPUs offer specialized acceleration for TensorFlow-based workflows, high scalability, and exceptional power efficiency in specific contexts. The choice between TPUs and GPUs depends on the specific requirements of the AI workload and the available infrastructure.
Gemini's latest achievement - TPU v5p
Google's latest achievement, the TPU v5p, was launched in December 2023 as a new cloud-based AI acceleration solution. It is hailed as the most powerful and scalable TPU chip to date. The TPU v5p delivers an incredible 2.8x speed improvement for training large language models, with HBM high-bandwidth memory increased by 3x and total FLOPs quadrupled. Compared to GPUs, TPUs exhibit superior computational power, excelling in large-scale training and deep neural network tasks, enabling customers to train large generative AI models faster. Google has been continuously refining its in-house AI chips, with the TPU evolving through generations of updates from 2016 to 2023, establishing Google TPU as a leader in the AI field. The debut of TPU v5p signifies a significant advancement for Google in its competition with Nvidia GPUs, presenting Nvidia, once the undisputed leader, with a commendable challenger.
RELATED TOPIC: FPGA vs CPU: Detailed Comparison Between FPGA and CPU
